A Season (or Two) in Review
OR "The one where KJ gets all weepy at the close of the season"
Five months ago, I wrote this:
For now, I say we embrace the high expectations. The defensive move as a fan would be to say that last season was (almost) as good as it gets; let's not expect the same sort of success in consecutive seasons. But, if this program is truly on the path to long-term eliteness, annually-lofty expectations come with the territory.
So with high expectations fully embraced, I foresee the following:
- A 12-1 nonnconference record. That means beating two good, but clearly less talented, teams (Gonzaga/Florida) in home/neutral settings and then knocking off one of two equally-talented teams (North Carolina/Texas) in more hostile settings. I'll say we beat a very young UNC team on their home court but lose to Texas in Austin.
- A 14-4 conference record. We drop, at most, one game at the Breslin Center; beat Iowa, Penn State, and Indiana on the road; and pull off road wins in 2-3 games against the 6 potential NCAA Tournament teams we play on the road (no Ohio State).
- That'd be good for a 26-5 record and, hopefully, at least a share of the Big Ten title going into postseason play. The Big Ten Tournament is always a crapshoot; if we're setting expectations high, though, a match-up with Purdue in the final (to perhaps break a regular season tie) would be lovely.
- Nothing's guaranteed in the NCAA Tournament, which is what makes it such a fabulous sporting event, but if everything plays out to form in the regular season, nothing short of another trip to Indianapolis (hopefully as a #1 seed) would be satisfactory.
Two for four ain't bad--especially since the two I got right are the two we care most about. MSU failed to meet the lofty preseason expectations during nonconference play and the Big Ten Tournament was a one-and-done disaster, but a 14-4 record was achieved in conference play (albeit not in the manner described above) and a trip to Indianapolis for the Final Four was taken (albeit as a #5 seed).
This Michigan State basketball season contained more ups and downs than any other of the Tom Izzo era:
- Up: A #2 preseason ranking.
- Down: The underwhelming nonconference performance.
- Up: A 9-0 Big Ten start.
- Down: A 3-game losing streak--centered around Kalin Lucas' first injury.
- Up: The recovery to gain a share of the conference title, led by senior captain Raymar Morgan.
- Down: The agonizing BTT loss.
- Up: The run to Indianapolis--despite Lucas' second injury and major physical obstacles for Chris Allen and Delvon Roe--as Durrell Summers and Korie Lucious step into the spotlight and Draymond Green assumes the mantle of team leader.
In the end, the team ranked #2 in the preseason polls finished #4 in the final poll of the season. That final ranking is, of course, a function of the fact that the coaches weight NCAA Tournament performance for approximately 90% of their scores, but the NCAA Tournament is where college basketball success is ultimately judged for a team playing at or near the top of the sport. (A respectable #13 in the final Sagarin Ratings, by the way.)
Stepping back a bit, here's what the last two seasons have brought us:
- 21 wins over KenPom top-50 teams.
- A 29-7 Big Ten record, including a 15-3 mark away from home.
- Two Big Ten championship banners.
- Two Final Four appearances.
- 11 NCAA Tournament games, 5 of them played within driving distance of East Lansing.
The second part of that final bullet has special meaning for me. I've had the good fortune to be able to see my team play on the sport's biggest stage in person for two consecutive years. The odds are high that won't happen again in my lifetime (without plane tickets being involved, at least). As far as sports fandom goes, these last two years have been about as memorable as they come.
Only two teams in the country can argue they've had more success over the last two seasons than Michigan State has--the two teams that have lifted the national championship trophy aloft at the close of the two seasons. Not coincidentally, those are also the only two programs still ahead of Michigan State in the hunt for national prestige of the contemporary variety (OK, maybe Kansas, too).
That hunt continues for Tom Izzo and his team next season (more on that soon). For now, I say, as heartily as ever, it's good to be a Spartan.
P.S. File under things you already knew: Worst One Shining Moment ever. Way too much about the singer. It's not just the cutaways to Jennifer Hudson. Her voice is just to big for the occasion. The understated version sung by the late Luther Vandross was much preferable in terms of allowing the drama of basketball moments to speak for itself. Surely, there's another artist out there who can similarly do justice to the tradition.
P.P.S. Let the Durrell Summers draftwatch commence.
27 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Ford's sources are not unimpeachable...
but that is not a good sign. Durrell is likely gone. Hopefully he at least doesn’t hire an agent so he can return if things go badly. But it doesn’t sound good.
No Summers and no Raymar. That’s a lot of production to replace.
It's kind of like replacing one player in a way
because, if I recall correctly, there were very few games this season when both Durrell and Raymar had good performances at the same time.
by Pete Rossman on Apr 6, 2010 11:50 PM CDT up reply actions
only in the tournament.
which is kind of a big deal.
Probably will declare but w/o an agent
When is the date for players declaring w/o agent to pull their name from the draft and return? You’d have to imagine Summers will initially test the waters to see where he’s projected.
Definitely will hurt to lose both Summers and Morgan.
Either Appling will have to contribute immediately....
or Allen will have to resume his role as primary gunner. His defensive specialist’s role may have to go away.
I don’t know where the 25 points a game are going to come from to replace those two.
Rexrode piece
Quote from another draft analyst:
“He definitely elevated his stock during the tournament, and I’d call him a potential first rounder,” said Chris Monter, an NBA draft analyst who publishes the Monter Draft News. “But if you’re not projected as a lottery pick, you probably shouldn’t go. If he plays next season like he did during the tournament, he’ll probably be a first-round pick.”
Rexrode paints a pretty dramatic picture of where things stood after the BTT—Summers was likely gone after this season, one way or another.
Fight for The Only Colors: Green and White!
by KJ@theonlycolors on Apr 7, 2010 8:34 AM CDT reply actions
Can anyone exlpain...
the whole comment about how people who followed MSU hoops closely thought he’d transfer to division II or play overseas? I am an MSU hoops junkie and I don’t remember ever seeing anyone say/mention that anywhere at any point.
I'm guessing this behind the scenes stuff
Part of what Izzo mentioned when he talked about writing a book on this season. Sounds like Izzo and Summers were very, very far apart during one point in the year. I heard a poster mention elsewhere (rather cryptically) that at least one person was probably gone unexpectedly at the end of the year. No reason to make stuff up and I imagine he was referring to Summers.
Summers
There is no way Summers should leave, from a b-ball perspective. He lacks the ball handling skills and defense to play the 2, his natural position in the NBA. This is a guy who has had two to three times as many turnovers as assists during his career at MSU. In the Butler game again, it was striking how little he could create on his own, even when he was being guarded by a 6-2 non-NBA guy. Also, he is a good shooter, though streaky, but it is not like he has extraordinary range.
There may be family reasons, and maybe there are issues with Izzo and teammates we don’t know about, but basketball wise, this strikes me as a total no-brainer. Hopefully, he explores the possibilities with Izzo but without an agent and comes back to MSU. I’m not opposed to juniors leaving — it’s a tough world — but this seems unlikely.
Durrell should go when his stock is highest
Durrell’s plan has always been to play in the NBA. I don’t see him coming back one more year and learning all of those things that he hasn’t already learned in three years here. As much as I would like him to stay, his draft stock will almost certainly not be higher next year. He is a big stage player and another year of inconsistencies (plus reduced playing time due to our depth) will more likely than not hurt him, not to mention the possibility of injuries. From an NBA standpoint he should capitalize right now and make the leap if he looks cemented in the first round. Next year there will be a wealth of swing men entering the draft as well.
A look on the bright side
If Summers has it on good authority that he is a first rounder, I see him going. Hopefully he makes a wise decision and not a purely emotional one. If he leaves, that opens a spot for Zeigler or one of the other unsigned, highly regarded recruits, whose eyes may have been opened to the Spartans after this year’s run. If Herzog decides to hang up the sneakers, Izzo could go for a bonanza class, or hold onto a scholarship for 2011. With Summers, as they say in the mutual fund business, past performance is no guarantee of future results. I loved what he could bring to the court, but he certainly didn’t bring it on a consistent basis.
I doubt that Zeigler is coming to Michigan State.
Michigan or UCLA. If Izzo is going to fill the spot, it will have to be via another recruit.
I hope it works out for Durrell. But given his height, inability to handle the basketball (our secondary ballhandler in the tourney was a 6’6" Dancing Bear), and somewhat limited shooting range (he hit 3s but he doesn’t have conisistent NBA range), I just don’t see it.
Hope I’m wrong. Despite his struggles, he’s come a long way and been a big-stage performer and one of our best-ever rebounding guards. But I just don’t see him sticking on an NBA roster, especially this year as anyone with a remote chance (perhaps even Kalin) is throwing their name in due to the lockout.
Summers may have to do what Bell did, go overseas and work his way back.
guarranteed contract
If he is a first rounder and can get a guarranted contract, then I agree it is a no brainer. It may be that there are risks to coming back for a senior year. On the other hand, the chances of making the NBA from the second round are vritually nill. The question is really whether ultimately he’ll make a good living in Europe playing ball, and whether he maxes his long term salary potential by leaving now.
#4 in the polls?
if we only lost by 2 points to #2 Butler, who only lost by 2 points to #1 Duke, why are we at #4, behind #3 West Virginia, who lost by 21(!) points to #1 Duke?
Because they basically use regular season performance as the tie-breaker for NCAA finish
WV was #5 in final regular season poll; MSU was #12.
- is plenty generous, IMO.
Fight for The Only Colors: Green and White!
by KJ@theonlycolors on Apr 7, 2010 11:51 AM CDT up reply actions
"1." = "#4"
Fight for The Only Colors: Green and White!
by KJ@theonlycolors on Apr 7, 2010 11:52 AM CDT up reply actions
Don't forget that there might not even be a 2011 draft.
If he has any chance at all of being a 1st round draft pick he HAS to go. steinfi2 is right. If he hasn’t learned how to dribble my now, it’s not going to happen.
I dunno
I think Summers is one of those rare guys who could use a great senior year to lock up a first-round spot and go higher next year. I don’t agree about the “chance at all.” He should be confident or get a guarantee. If he’s on the bubble, he’s gotta come back.
He's not going to shoot better than he did in tourney through out the season.
He’s shot 37% from 3 the past 2 seasons. NBA execs/GM draft on upside regardless of how absurd it is. If he comes back next year do you see the turnover issues disappearing? He may be able to reduce the turnovers if the NCAA gets rid of the absurd imaginary circle and actually paints one (He seems to have a lot of offensive fouls.) He would have to have a monster season to see his stock increase significantly more than it is now. I just don’t see him averaging more than 12-15 points per game with Lucas out to prove he’s NBA material. Not to mention Green’s almost certain shot% increase.
by Chris in Kzoo on Apr 7, 2010 2:18 PM CDT up reply actions
Judgment call, no doubt
But I don’t think Summers needs to get 18-8 to improve his stock. 14-6 on a loaded team who goes deep into the tournament could be enough. I think he could demonstrate a better handle and a better basket attacking game during his senior year. It’s consistency more than a jump in peak production that has to happen. If Summers played like the tournament all year, he’s already locked in the first round. Do it all of next year and he is again.
But we’ll see. You may very well be right, but I would hate to see him leave and go in round two because I am sure that first round status is within his potential.
True
Points per game isn’t everything. Being a key player on a deep team could be enough. Marvin Williams comes to mind. Not the best example, but he came off the bench for 11 points and 6 rebounds a game and was drafted 2nd overall.
Williams was also a Freshman, not a senior. He's also 6-9.
I’m not saying that Summers wouldn’t become a better player staying another year, just that the risks outweigh the rewards. He’s not going to become a lottery player by staying another year. Whatever decision he and his family make, I hope its for the best.
by Chris in Kzoo on Apr 7, 2010 3:41 PM CDT up reply actions
But he might become a first-rounder by staying (if he isn't already)
Especially given the lockout situation – if he can afford to sit tight and hope that a deal is reached and the season goes off as scheduled, there may well be a smaller draft class that year.
If he’s got someone who he can be sure will take him in the first, then he should go. If not, unless he needs money now for family reasons (and is willing to go to the Euro leagues if he gets picked in the second round and gets cut), he should probably stay.
Better One Shining Moment
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=igKlLyAvSEk
"You think our war drill is something now. Next year is going to be fist fighting."- Tom Izzo
Go Spartans
Thank You VERY much!
Love it. Thanks for posting the link. Thanks to the young Dukie for fixing that horrendous version that was showed Monday night.
First off
What a fantastic two years this has been. Four banners hanging in the rafters, and possibly the most exciting (i.e. heartstopping) run to the Final Four in Tournament history. I did not expect this team to make a deep tournament run this year, so everything after the New Mexico State game really seemed like gravy. Despite not living up to expectations efficiency-wise, we managed to tie for another Big Ten regular season title.
As far as what next year holds, I have pretty high expectations assuming Lucas, Roe and Allen can return to full strength. Losing Morgan is a blow, and a departure by Summers would be another, but I think we could weather the losses provided those three return healthy. As far as the NBA decision goes, I hope Summers makes whatever decision is best for him and if he leaves I wish him well. If he stays I hope he plays as well as he did in the tournament his whole senior year and solidifies his draft status.
The key will be Nix and Sherman improving on defense – if we can get solid minutes from both next year we’ll be longer and bigger, and hopefully they can replace some of what is lost on offense with the departure of Morgan.

by 





















