Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: The Amateur Mathematics Of Linsanity

Musing Through the MSU Depth Chart

I may be a basketball-inclined college sports blogger, but I could certainly have done with less basketball-related news over this past MSU sports blogging offseason.  It's made for great traffic and commenting levels, but it's also induced way too much offseason stress and introduced too many question marks for the the upcoming basketball season.

I'm going to go ahead and declare the Offseason of Tumult over.  (I presume all individuals associated with MSU athletics will recognize my authority in this area and adhere to the edict.)  After all, we've got a real, live regular season football depth chart now.  And real, live Spartan sports action is less than 100 hours away.

Joe Rexrode has already covered the major data points to be gleaned from the depth chart.  Building off his work, here are my own musings:

  • Very nice to not have an "OR" at the quarterback spot this fall.  I'm a numbers guy, so I don't tend to put a lot of stock in intangibles, but having a clear leader at the quarterback spot has to be worth something.
  • Making Andrew Maxwell the back-up quarterback is absolutely the right move.  In the horrific scenario that Kirk Cousins goes down for the season, the coaching staff would no doubt take a hard look at moving Keith Nichol back to quarterback and making him the starter.  Short of that, having a back-up quarterback who's spending his 100% of his time focused on the position is what you want.
  • Four co-starters at the two receiver spots: B.J. Cunningham, Mark Dell, Keshawn Martin, Nichol.  I'd think Cunningham and Dell are the favorites to see the most playing time in two-WR sets, as they continue to work themselves back into Mark Dantonio's good graces from the dorm assault incident.  (Martin and Nichol were listed as the only starters on the spring depth chart.)  Martin and Nichol will certainly see lots of time on the field, though.  The trick play options when both of them are on the field are almost limitless.  I'm thinking flea-flicker/throw-back/reverse/option-pass.
  • Four tight tends who will contribute.  We knew that already, of course.
  • Le'Veon Bell is the only tailback listed behind Edwin Baker and Larry Caper.  As noted by LVS in his post on the rushing game, Bell looks tantalizingly goalline-backish at 6'2", 230 pounds.  Caper is expected to play against Western despite suffering some sort of arm/wrist injury that has him wearing a cast.
  • I'd forgotten about Fred Smith moving to fullback.  He's the back-up behind Josh Rouse.
  • Offensive line had already pretty much shaken itself out.  He locked up the position early and hasn't gotten a lot of attention of late (very likely a good thing), but I still think D.J. Young may be the most important player on this team, protecting Cousins' backside.  Young's a senior, but he's also going into just his second season as an active MSU player after transferring from Bowling Green.  Hopefully, his experience at right tackle last season translates well to the left side.
  • The depth chart reinforces how young the defensive line is: Of the 12 players listed are, 8 are freshmen or sophomores.  We'll be watching one of those young linemen just a little more than the others: William Gholston is listed as the back-up (behind co-starters) at the "RUSH" end position.  Three "OR"s among the 4 defensive line spots, so lots of opportunities for people to make themselves factors.  Blake Treadwell is questionable for Saturday's game with a leg injury.
  • No surprises at linebacker or in the secondary.  Lots of freshmen once you get past the starters in the defensive backfield.  (Sidenote: After the disaster that was the MSU pass defense last season, who would have thought that the weakest Big Ten secondary in the state would reside in Ann Arbor?)
  • Final "OR" is at placekicker: Dan Conroy and Kevin Muma.  Barring catastrophe, there should be a couple of weeks to sort that out before there's the potential for a game-deciding field goal attempt.

Final bit: Rexrode reports that the team has something called a "unity council": a group of 12 players from which the 4th weekly rotating captain will be selected (joining Cousins, Greg Jones, and Aaron Bates).  Sounds a little too much like a part of a communist leadership apparatus, but anything that helps keep the entire roster on the straight and narrow off the field is a good thing in my book.

On that note, we've come full circle back to off-the-field/court tumult.  Let the games begin!

Comment 6 comments  |  0 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

Comments

Display:

My hopes for WMU

1. Play the young guys: Did we really need 5 TDs and 34 carries out of Javon Ringer against EMU in 2008? We should’ve been giving Anderson, Leggett, etc. more carries and game experience. With Caper hobbled I’d like to see Bell and even Hill get some good looks.

2. Kick Field Goals: In 2005 I specifically remember running up the score against Kent State wondering why we didn’t try and give Goss some FG opportunities (especially since somebody blew a PAT earlier in the game).

by RickTheBloggerMartel on Sep 1, 2010 7:53 AM CDT reply actions  

Agree

But, you also want to give your starters a good amount of work. Afterall this is their first live action of the season. I’d expect them to play into the third quarter regardless of score (unless things get completely out of hand in the first half).

That said,I’d like to see Maxwell get some significant playing time in the second half.

I wouldn’t mind seeing Hill get some carries, although it sounds like they may consider trying to redshirt him this year. Since he didn’t appear on the depth chart. Does anyone know how many games can you appear in early in the season without burning your redshirt?

by trivialstuff16 on Sep 1, 2010 8:20 AM CDT up reply actions  

A spectre is haunting East Lansing...

As long as we don’t start calling the four weekly captains the “Politburo,” I think we can hold the phone to Sen. McCarthy!

I wonder what kind of casted arm injury Caper has that allows him to carry the ball effectively.

by intrpdtrvlr on Sep 1, 2010 9:28 AM CDT reply actions  

Le'Veon

Excited to finally see this kid in action. Howard Griffith of BTN said during the MSU preview special and again during the overall Big Ten preview that he thinks Bell will eventually become the starter this year. While that may be farfetched given the sophomores ahead of him, I would settle for “guy who can get us a tough yard” in 3rd and 1 situations.

by Ducking Delvon on Sep 1, 2010 11:14 AM CDT reply actions  

Most exciting part about this depth chart, is depth.

I’m as interested in which of these guys will end up in what roles as anyone. Whether Bell becomes the short yardage back or not, how often they use the 3-4 to get more linebackers on the field, whether they are going to run a lot of 4 wideout sets to get all of those guys on the field etc.

But really, all of those things are nice discussions made possible by a major upgrade in the top to bottom depth on this team. That’s what I find most encouraging. Because the chances of all 4 of those wideouts staying healthy all season is slim. Ditto at all of these other positions. It’s nice to feel like at a lot of these spots we have starter level talent in a lot of spots.

Obviously you can’t afford to lose stars. I like our depth on the Defensive line, but nobody on that depth chart has Worthy’s disruptive potential so we need him to stay healthy. Same story at some other areas. And obviously there are some areas that don’t look as deep.

I’m glad that those young guys in the secondary are getting nice reviews, but I sure would like to have a few more known qualities back there.

All in all, what strikes me about this roster is that top to bottom is the deepest I can remember.

by trivialstuff16 on Sep 1, 2010 12:26 PM CDT reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

A Michigan State basketball and football blog community

FanPosts


Managers

Petenewpic_small Pete Rossman

Spiritofd_small LVS

Contributors

Square_sun_small Steve Hendershot

Marvin_small SpartanDan

State_small Con-T

Adorno5_small intrpdtrvlr

Patrickhayes_small patrick_hayes

Keep-calm-carry-on_small HeckDorland